Youngstown Local Index logoYOUNGSTOWNLOCAL INDEX

YOUNGSTOWN
BUSINESS DIRECTORY

Add a listing

Built for a city that makes its own way.

Youngstown Local Index

Brier Hill Pizza: A Youngstown Original

Youngstown has its own style of pizza, and locals are proud of it. Brier Hill pizza is a thick, saucy pie topped with bell peppers and grated Romano cheese, and traditionally no mozzarella at all.

Where It Began

The style takes its name from Brier Hill, a historic Youngstown neighborhood that was home to many Italian immigrant families who worked in the nearby steel mills. Home cooks made pizza with ingredients from their gardens, especially tomatoes and peppers, and topped it with the hard grated cheese they had on hand.

What Makes It Different

  • A thick, bready crust
  • A generous layer of chunky red sauce
  • Bell peppers baked right into the sauce
  • Grated Romano cheese instead of mozzarella

The result is closer to a tomato pie than a typical cheese pizza, with bold sauce and pepper flavor.

Church Festivals and Family Kitchens

Brier Hill pizza became a favorite at Italian church festivals and family gatherings. Many people first tried it at a parish festival before finding it at local pizzerias.

Finding It Today

A number of Valley pizzerias and bakeries offer Brier Hill style pizza, sometimes by the slice and sometimes by the sheet. Ask local friends for their favorites, since everyone seems to have a strong opinion.

Make It at Home

To try it yourself, use a thick pan crust, a hearty sauce with sauteed bell peppers and a generous dusting of Romano. Bake until the crust is golden and the sauce is bubbling.

Part of Youngstown Identity

Like the cookie table, Brier Hill pizza reflects the immigrant families who built the Valley. It is simple, hearty food with a story, and it remains a favorite for game days, parties and family dinners.

Pair It With Other Local Favorites

Many families serve Brier Hill pizza alongside wedding soup, greens and beans or homemade cookies for a true taste of the Valley.

Discover More With Youngstown Local Index

Use Youngstown Local Index to find local businesses, services and places across Youngstown, Boardman, Austintown, Canfield, Poland, Niles, Warren and the rest of the Mahoning Valley. If you need a process server, a private investigator or BCI and FBI fingerprinting, Ohio Security & Investigations at 7087 West Blvd #8 in Youngstown can help. Call (888) 341-6960.